obsolete

docs/training/corpus/Layer_0--Primitive_Facts/CORPUS-0023-ownership-use-and-income-can-separate.md

@@ -1,124 +0,0 @@
-# CORPUS-0023
-## Ownership, Use, And Income Can Separate
-### Status: Training Corpus Seed
-### Layer: Layer_0--Primitive_Facts
-### Purpose: Teach that owning an asset, using it, controlling it, earning from it, and claiming against it may belong to different actors
-### Repository Path: docs/training/corpus/Layer_0--Primitive_Facts/CORPUS-0023-ownership-use-and-income-can-separate.md
-
----
-
-## 0. Principle
-
-Ownership, use, income, custody, and claim are not always held by the same person.
-
-One actor may own an asset.
-
-Another may use it.
-
-Another may collect income from it.
-
-Another may hold a claim against it.
-
-Another may control access to it in practice.
-
-The model must not assume that possession, ownership, and economic benefit are the same condition.
-
----
-
-## 1. Roman-Visible Example
-
-A building in Ostia may involve several different economic positions:
-
-- one family owns the building
-- a shopkeeper rents the front room
-- a warehouse clerk controls access to stored goods
-- tenants pay rent for upper rooms
-- a creditor holds a claim against future rent
-- a trader has temporary storage permission in one corner
-
-The building is one asset.
-
-The economic rights around it are several.
-
----
-
-## 2. Minimal Separation Structure
-
-For any asset, the model should ask:
-
-1. who owns it?
-2. who possesses or occupies it?
-3. who may use it?
-4. who collects income from it?
-5. who pays upkeep?
-6. who controls access?
-7. who bears risk of damage?
-8. who has a claim against it?
-9. who can transfer or restrict use?
-10. who recognizes these arrangements?
-
-A single asset can support multiple relationships.
-
----
-
-## 3. Incorrect Modern Assumption
-
-Incorrect assumption:
-
-> The person using an asset owns it and receives all value from it.
-
-Correction:
-
-> The user of an asset may be a renter, custodian, borrower, tenant, agent, or temporary right-holder.
-
-Likewise, the owner may not directly use the asset or receive immediate coin from it.
-
----
-
-## 4. Simulation Use
-
-This principle supports:
-
-- rental income
-- tenancy
-- warehouse custody
-- storage rights
-- building ownership
-- land use
-- cart hire
-- ship shares
-- debt claims
-- collateral
-- agency relationships
-- maintenance obligations
-- disputes over title, use, or income
-
-The model should represent asset relationships as separable claims and roles, not as a single ownership flag.
-
----
-
-## 5. Canonical Test
-
-If the model sees:
-
-> The trader uses warehouse space.
-
-It must ask:
-
-- does he own the warehouse?
-- is he renting the space?
-- is it temporary use?
-- who controls access?
-- who earns from the arrangement?
-- who bears damage risk?
-- who can remove him?
-- is there a creditor or prior claimant?
-- is the right recorded, witnessed, or informal?
-
-Only then can the economic position be understood.
-
----
-
-## 6. Success Condition
-
-If the model stops collapsing ownership, use, income, custody, and claim into one state and starts tracking them as separable economic relationships, this file is functioning correctly.