initial upload

docs/law/DIALOGUE-LAW-0001.md

@@ -0,0 +1,444 @@
+# DIALOGUE-LAW-0001
+## The Fallen Beam — Canonical Draft
+### Status: Canonical Dialogue Draft
+### Layer: OTIVM (Roman Law)
+### Purpose: Opening law-phase scenario teaching status conversion, debt bondage, contractual obligation, liability after workplace death, family exposure, standing to sue, and the difference between justice and enforceability.
+### Repository Path: docs/scenarios/DIALOGUE-LAW-0001.md
+
+---
+
+## 0. Design Intent
+
+A former merchant of Ostia entered bondage under debt arrangement to shield his household from creditors.
+
+Three weeks later, while laboring in a contracted demolition, he was crushed by a falling beam.
+
+No riot has begun. No magistrate has ruled. No property burned.
+
+Yet creditors gather, the contractor blames chance, the owner claims loss, the widow asks whether promises still stand, and neighbors debate whether a dead man completed his bargain.
+
+Known facts are uncertain:
+
+- was the site negligent or merely dangerous
+- did the debt arrangement free his family fully or partly
+- was he purchased as labor, time, or collateral
+- did the owner breach duties of care
+- can anyone sue with standing
+- will anyone powerful care enough to act
+
+The participant must learn that law often decides what a death means economically.
+
+---
+
+## 1. Scene Constraints
+
+Location: street outside a timber yard and partially demolished warehouse in Ostia, late morning after funeral rites.
+
+Primary signals:
+
+- broken beam still visible inside site
+- widow speaking with two creditors
+- contractor loudly denying fault
+- laborers whispering about unsafe orders
+- scribe offering to inspect documents
+- crowd discussing whether debt survives
+
+Selection method: participant chooses whose interpretation to follow.
+
+---
+
+## 2. Opening Scene Draft
+
+The beam that killed him still lay where it had fallen.
+
+One end rested in dust and broken tile. The other pinned a smashed handcart nobody had yet bothered to move. Men pointed at it with confidence they had lacked yesterday.
+
+Marcus Atilius Varro stood at the yard gate watching workers avoid the place where death had become expensive.
+
+Lucius Fabius Felix arrived smiling less than usual and only because tragedy still traded.
+
+“No fire. No flood. No edict,” Felix said. “Only a corpse and six arguments.”
+
+Varro looked toward the widow.
+
+“Eight arguments.”
+
+Felix counted two creditors, a contractor, a steward, the widow, three neighbors.
+
+“Good. The city still multiplies.”
+
+Gaius Licinius Crispus approached with deliberate gravity.
+
+“Has any official seal been placed on the site?”
+
+Felix answered first.
+
+“Only dust.”
+
+Crispus ignored him.
+
+“No closure,” Varro said. “Work resumed at dawn in the rear wall.”
+
+“Predictable,” Crispus said.
+
+Quintus Cornelius Lentulus Minor arrived beneath a restrained cloak suitable for sympathy at moderate distance.
+
+“I knew the man by sight,” Lentulus said. “He sold lamp oil once.”
+
+Felix nodded.
+
+“And later sold himself.”
+
+“That is coarse.”
+
+“That is sequence.”
+
+Titus Varenus Secundus emerged from inside the yard carrying a split wedge of oak.
+
+“Bad staging,” he said. “Beam should have been braced twice.”
+
+Varro turned.
+
+“Certain?”
+
+Secundus held up the wedge.
+
+“This was cracked before yesterday.”
+
+A quiet voice came from beside the widow.
+
+“And still charged at full quality.”
+
+Publius Terentius Chresimus stood with two tablets already open.
+
+Felix sighed.
+
+“Even grief acquires accounting.”
+
+“It arrived with accounting,” Chresimus said.
+
+The widow was arguing with a narrow man in clean sandals.
+
+“You said the debt was ended!”
+
+He replied:
+
+“I said reduced according to term.”
+
+Half the crowd leaned closer.
+
+Varro said, “There.”
+
+“What?” Lentulus asked.
+
+“The real body.”
+
+Crispus nodded reluctantly.
+
+“The contract.”
+
+The contractor shouted from the yard entrance:
+
+“He ignored orders! Entered before signal!”
+
+A laborer muttered loudly enough to be heard:
+
+“No signal was given.”
+
+The contractor suddenly discovered other business.
+
+Felix smiled.
+
+“Witnesses ripen quickly in sunlight.”
+
+Lentulus frowned.
+
+“If the man entered bondage lawfully, his owner bears some duty.”
+
+Felix looked impressed.
+
+“Education survives breeding.”
+
+Crispus said, “Duty depends on form. If leased labor through contractor, burdens split.”
+
+Chresimus added:
+
+“If documents exist.”
+
+Secundus pointed toward the beam.
+
+“Documents do not brace timber.”
+
+Varro almost smiled.
+
+A second creditor arrived carrying an older tablet and greater confidence.
+
+He announced that household utensils remained pledged.
+
+The widow said the husband entered bondage precisely to prevent that.
+
+The creditor replied:
+
+“Then we must determine whether he completed performance.”
+
+The crowd made the low sound crowds make when cruelty speaks politely.
+
+Felix said softly:
+
+“There is your lesson.”
+
+Lentulus looked displeased.
+
+“Can they truly argue this?”
+
+Crispus answered first.
+
+“They can argue anything. Success costs extra.”
+
+Chresimus examined one tablet.
+
+“Interesting.”
+
+“What?” Varro asked.
+
+“The debt amount differs between copies.”
+
+Felix laughed once.
+
+“At last. Civilization.”
+
+Secundus crouched beside the beam scar.
+
+“See scrape marks. They moved support posts after loading.”
+
+Varro said, “To save time?”
+
+“To save wood.”
+
+Crispus looked toward the contractor.
+
+“If proven, negligence strengthens claim.”
+
+“Whose claim?” Felix asked.
+
+The question sat in the dust.
+
+Lentulus answered:
+
+“The widow.”
+
+Crispus shook his head.
+
+“Not certain.”
+
+“The family.”
+
+“Not certain.”
+
+“The dead man’s kin.”
+
+“Depends.”
+
+Felix spread his hands.
+
+“There. Law enters.”
+
+Chresimus said, “Owner may claim loss of purchased labor value.”
+
+The crowd turned sharply.
+
+Lentulus said, “Absurd.”
+
+“Common,” Chresimus replied.
+
+Secundus muttered:
+
+“Then buy oxen instead.”
+
+A laborer approached quietly.
+
+“He complained yesterday.”
+
+“About what?” Varro asked.
+
+“Loose joints. Said roof leaned wrong.”
+
+“Will you testify?” Crispus asked.
+
+The man looked at the contractor, then at his hungry sandals.
+
+“How much does truth pay?”
+
+Felix admired him openly.
+
+“A philosopher.”
+
+The widow began crying not loudly, but efficiently.
+
+Two neighbors moved beside her.
+
+The first creditor stepped back half a pace.
+
+Varro noticed.
+
+“Pressure works.”
+
+Chresimus nodded.
+
+“Public sympathy lowers collection appetite.”
+
+Felix said, “Temporarily.”
+
+Lentulus looked toward the widow.
+
+“My household could intervene.”
+
+Felix turned.
+
+“Out of virtue?”
+
+“Out of order.”
+
+“More believable.”
+
+Crispus asked, “What exactly did he sign?”
+
+Chresimus lifted a copy.
+
+“Not enough. It states service until debt satisfaction under valuation schedule.”
+
+Secundus said, “Meaning?”
+
+“It means everyone will claim meaning.”
+
+The contractor returned with sudden confidence.
+
+“The man was warned. Many heard it.”
+
+No one nearby had.
+
+Varro asked, “Who owns the yard?”
+
+“A partnership.”
+
+“Named?”
+
+The contractor hesitated.
+
+Felix smiled slowly.
+
+“There.”
+
+“What?” Lentulus asked.
+
+“The next corpse.”
+
+Crispus straightened.
+
+“If partnership assets touched this, records matter greatly.”
+
+A clerk from the magistrate’s office appeared at the lane mouth.
+
+Instant silence.
+
+He announced no hearing had been ordered, but complaints could be submitted in proper form with fee.
+
+The crowd began speaking again, angrier and poorer.
+
+Felix said, “And now justice has admission price.”
+
+Crispus replied sharply.
+
+“Procedure has cost.”
+
+“Same gate.”
+
+Varro asked, “What matters now?”
+
+Secundus answered first.
+
+“Who saw the supports moved.”
+
+Lentulus said, “Who shields the widow.”
+
+Crispus said, “Who has standing and coin to file.”
+
+Felix said, “Who settles fastest from fear.”
+
+Chresimus said, “What the contract valued.”
+
+They all looked at him.
+
+“If he sold time, debt remains partly. If labor output, maybe remains mostly. If person entirely, owner claims loss. Words decide grief.”
+
+Varro stepped toward the laborers.
+
+“I’ll find men who saw yesterday.”
+
+Secundus moved with him.
+
+“I’ll inspect the staging and timber.”
+
+Lentulus adjusted his cloak.
+
+“I will speak with the widow before creditors do.”
+
+Crispus drew himself up.
+
+“I will determine viable claims.”
+
+Felix turned toward the two creditors.
+
+“I will discover how cheaply certainty can be bought.”
+
+Chresimus tied his tablets.
+
+“I will compare every copy of every promise.”
+
+Felix looked back once.
+
+“Six men. One dead merchant. None of us discussing mourning.”
+
+Varro answered without turning.
+
+“We are discussing what death now owes.”
+
+---
+
+## 3. Choice Presentation
+
+> The man is buried. His obligations are not. Whose reading of the yard do you trust?
+
+| Choice | Background |
+|---|---|
+| Follow Varro to locate witnesses and practical facts. | Former Legionary |
+| Follow Felix to exploit fear, settlement, and creditor panic. | Freedman Trader |
+| Follow Lentulus to shield the widow through patronage and status. | Noble Younger Son |
+| Follow Crispus to test standing, filings, and liability. | Failed Magistrate |
+| Follow Secundus to inspect the site, supports, and negligence. | Camp Logistician |
+| Follow Chresimus to decode contracts, copies, and debt meaning. | Guild Scribe |
+
+---
+
+## 4. What This Scene Teaches
+
+- Status can be converted into bondage under pressure.
+- Death does not automatically end obligations.
+- Contract wording can decide family survival.
+- Negligence matters only if someone can press it.
+- Witnesses are valuable and reluctant.
+- Justice and enforceability are separate questions.
+
+---
+
+## 5. Canonical Success Condition
+
+If the participant stops asking:
+
+“Who was at fault?”
+
+and starts asking:
+
+“What exactly was bought, promised, and still enforceable?”
+
+then this dialogue is functioning correctly.